MTB Tire Guide

Continental Argotal vs Specialized Butcher

Short answer: Rolling resistance: Continental Argotal leads with 46.5 W, Specialized Butcher trails by 3.6 W.

Configure your build

Width, casing, compound and pressure – every value on this page follows your pick.

Continental Argotal

Tire width
Wheel size
27.5" wheel
29" wheel
Casing
Compound
Pressure (context)
Measured point

Specialized Butcher

Tire width
Wheel size
27.5" wheel
29" wheel
Compound
Pressure (context)
Measured point
Measured value available
How we calculate

Width, casing and compound decide how a tire really rides. We only show what was actually measured – and label estimates honestly.

Continental Argotal: Reference: documented test pressure of the source (24.7 psi (1.70 bar)).

Specialized Butcher: Reference: test pressure 24.7 psi (1.70 bar).

More pressure: less rolling resistance, less grip, less comfort. Tougher casing: more protection, more weight. Softer compound: more grip, more rolling resistance.

Modelled values are assumptions based on the stated measurement points – not a lab test.

Size, weight and casing

Continental ArgotalSpecialized Butcher
Width2.4" · 2.6" (60 · 65 mm)2.3" · 2.6" (58 · 66 mm)
Wheel sizes27.5" · 29"27.5" · 29"
Weight1,040 g (29x2.4 Trail Endurance)1,180 g (29x2.3 GRID Gravity)
CasingTrail · 3-plyGRID Gravity · 2-ply
CasingTrail · Enduro · DownhillTrail · Enduro
TPI18060
Tread type–Aggressive
Tubeless readyyesyes
E-MTB approvalyes (E-25)yes
Price from€65€59
Model year20222011

Rubber compounds

Hardness scale 1 = hard and fast to 5 = very soft and grippy (our own classification).

Continental Argotal

Grip class: Grip

Specialized Butcher

Grip class: Max Grip

Different grip classes: the softer tire must roll slower. Read the watts with that in mind.

Specialized Butcher offers the softer compound range – more grip, usually at the cost of wear.

Lab data per version

Continental ArgotalSpecialized Butcher
Rolling resistance (W)46.5 W
50.1 W
Impact protection (%)19.5 %
56.8 %
Puncture resistance (N)–508.4 N
Weighed weight (g)1,227.0 g
1,334.0 g

These two tires have no measured values from the same test series. A direct comparison of numbers would not be sound.

Continental Argotal

Specialized Butcher

All tested versions

Test series: ENDURO Mountainbike Magazine – Labortest 64 Reifen

Measured values per compound and casing from the same laboratory test. Empty cells mean no reliable value was published.

Butcher T9 Grid Gravity29 x 2.4050.1 W
56.77 %
1334 g
70 €
Butcher T9 Grid Trail29 x 2.4051.4 W
28.18 %
1082 g
60 €

Rolling resistance

lower is better

  • Butcher T9 Grid Gravity50.1 W
  • Butcher T9 Grid Trail51.4 W

Impact protection

higher is better

  • Butcher T9 Grid Gravity56.77 %
  • Butcher T9 Grid Trail28.18 %

Compounds & versions as curves

Up to three versions at once: the curve is modelled rolling resistance across pressure, the dot is the real lab measurement. Click the legend to show or hide a version.

14.542.670.798.8126.8121927344249Pressure (psi)W
  • 46.2 W at 26 psi (1.79 bar) · Reference
    Puncture
    –
    Weight
    1071 g
  • 29.3 W at 26 psi (1.79 bar) · -16.9 W
    Puncture
    19.53 %
    Weight
    1227 g
  • 50.1 W at 26 psi (1.79 bar) · +3.9 W
    Puncture
    56.77 %
    Weight
    1334 g
  • 51.4 W
    Puncture
    28.18 %
    Weight
    1082 g

Without a lab test pressure we anchor the measured watt value at the recommended pressure. The curve shape is a physics model, not a measurement. Labs do not measure grip across pressure – we do not invent that curve. Wet grip is a lab value per tire model, not per version.

Three curves at most – hide one first.

Variants head to head

Every measured variant of the selected tires – the same model in another compound, width or casing sits right next to it. Empty fields mean no reliable measurement.

Continental ArgotalArgotal SuperSoft Compound Enduro-Casing46.5 W
19.53 %
1227 g
Specialized ButcherButcher T9 Grid Gravity50.1 W
56.77 %
1334 g
Specialized ButcherButcher T9 Grid Trail51.4 W
28.18 %
1082 g
Specialized ButcherButcher T9 Grid Trail · BIKE-Labor46.2 W
–1071 g

Charts

Rolling resistance (fewer watts is better)

Impact protection (higher is better)

Editorial rating (higher is better)

At least one tire is missing too many editorial scores for a radar profile. We never draw missing values as zero.

TestedYour build – derived

Recommendation by use

  • Fast laps and long climbs: Continental Argotal rolls easier at 46.5 W.
  • Bike park, rocks and e-MTB: Specialized Butcher protects better with 57% impact protection.

Tested

  • Rolling resistance: Continental Argotal leads with 46.5 W, Specialized Butcher trails by 3.6 W.
  • Impact protection: Specialized Butcher leads with 56.8 %, Continental Argotal trails by 37.2 %.
  • Weighed weight: Continental Argotal leads with 1,227 g, Specialized Butcher trails by 107 g.

Tests and sources

Continental Argotal

  • In this short test, BIKE pairs the coarse Argotal at the front with the Kryptotal at the rear to see if it's the ideal combo for enduro riders. The Argotal proves especially strong on loose and soft terrain, providing plenty of confidence there. It is rated a clear recommendation for loose ground.

    BIKE Magazin

Specialized Butcher

  • The editorial team tested the revised Specialized Butcher on trail and enduro terrain. The tire impresses with noticeably more cornering support and reliable grip on varying surfaces. Paired with the Eliminator, it forms a well-matched combo for aggressive riders.

    MTB-News.de
  • ENDURO's lab test measures 64 MTB tires under standardised conditions (20 km/h, 1.5 bar, 50 kg wheel load) for rolling resistance, pinch-flat protection and puncture resistance. Key takeaway: weight and pinch-flat protection are closely linked, while rolling resistance depends mainly on the rubber compound. Summarised in our own words; details and measured values at the original.

    ENDURO Mountainbike Magazine – Labortest

More head-to-heads